Sweetie's Pie Club

$66.00

Treat yourself or someone you love to a specialty pie every month, made just for Club members. These one-of-a-kind pies feature creative flavours and the best local ingredients, and aren’t available in-store.

Each membership includes:

One unique pie each month
Pick up at Niagara Food Co. on the third Friday or Saturday of each month
Start any month and keep going for 3, 6 or 12 months
A little in-store special just for Club members each month

We’ll email you a reminder the Tuesday before your pick-up date.

Please note: Shipping or Delivery not available. PICK UP ONLY.

View 2025-2026 Pie Calendars

Selection Your Duration & Savings 3 Months $22 ea • 6 Months $20 ea • 12 Months $18 ea

Prepaid Subscriptions 3 Months 6 Months 12 Months

Is this a gift? Give the gift of pie! No Yes

Start Date Right Away Future

HOW IT WORKS

Our Pie of the Month Club is made for flavour lovers who can’t wait to try something new. Each month, we bake a unique, gourmet pie in limited quantities exclusively for Club members. You’ll taste bold recipes that showcase Niagara’s best local ingredients, plus inspiration from flavours around the world.

Your membership begins in the month you choose and continues for 3, 6, or 12 consecutive months. We’ll email you a reminder the Tuesday before each pick-up, and each month you’ll also enjoy an exclusive in-store special just for Club Members.

Pick-up details: Club pies are ready for pick-up at Niagara Food Co [directions] on the third Friday (9am to 6pm) or Saturday (8am to 4pm) of each month.

Need to make a substitution? Let us know at least 48 hours before pick-up and we can swap your Club pie for one of our Signature or Specialty pies.

Please note: Shipping is not available. Pick-up only.

Here is the 2025 Sweetie's Pie Club line-up...

January 17, 18: Cranberry Lime Pie
February 21, 22: German Chocolate Pie
March 21, 22: Shoofly Pie
April 25, 26: Lemon Icebox Pie
May 16, 17: S'More Pie
June 20, 21: Strawberry Chess Pie
July 18, 19: Cherry Rhubarb Crostada
August 15, 16: Peaches and Ice Cream Pie
September 19, 20: Berry Cream Pie
October 24, 25: Miso Caramel Apple Pie
November 14, 15: Peanut Butter Pie
December 12, 13: Praline Pumpkin Pecan Pie

Ready to join?

Choose your start month and subscription length above to get started.

Coming in 2026...

January: Cranberry Orange Coconut Crumble Pie
February: Dark Chocolate Raspberry Chambord Galette
March: Maple Walnut Pie
April: Lemon Icebox Pie
May: Nutella Bailey’s Surprise Pie
June: Strawberry Balsamic Cheesecake Pie
July: Cherry Ginger Pie
August: Peach and Nectarine Crisp
September: Grape Galette
October: Sweet Potato Pie
November: Black Forrest Pie
December: Lemon Cranberry Chess Pie