Pie Club

Join our Pie-of-the-Month Club and give the greatest gift ever: pie!

Pie of the Month Club

$55.00$195.00

Our Pie of the Month Club gives you the opportunity to gift someone (or yourself) gourmet, specialty pies made with the best ingredients Niagara has to offer that aren’t available for purchase in store.

Please note we deliver only to St Catharines, Thorold, Niagara Falls, and Niagara-on-the-Lake but PICK UP is always available!

Give the gift that keeps on giving!

Our Pie of the Month Club gives you the opportunity to gift someone (or yourself) gourmet, specialty pies made with the best ingredients Niagara has to offer that aren’t available for purchase in-store.

At the beginning of each month, on the pre-determined dates listed below, your POTM will be ready and waiting for you as well as our recommendations on what best to pair with it (other than more pie)!

Here’s what your giftee (or yourself) will have ready and waiting for them each month!

Please note: Shipping is not available. Pick up only.

*Monthly pick-ups will be at the bakery on the set Fridays between 9am and 6pm and Saturdays between 8am and 4pm. Reminders will be emailed the Monday before pick up. If you are unable to make one of the pick-up dates, please call 289-669-0152 to make arrangements!

Sweetie’s Pie Club 2023
January 20-21: Dulce de Leche Cream Pie
February 17-18: Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Pie
March 17-18: Maple Chess Pie
April 21-22: Atlantic Cheesecake Pie
May 19-20: Pina Colada Pie
June 16-17: Strawberry Cobbler Pie
July 21-22: Apricot Amaretto Pie
August 18-19: Blueberry Blackcurrant Pie
September 15-16: Pear Plum Crisp
October 20-21: Apple Quince Pie
November 17-18: Earl Grey Crème Caramel Pie
December 15-16: Cranberry Dream Pie

Ready, set – sign up for Pie of the Month Club!

Additional information

Subscription Type

12 Months, 6 Months, 3 Months